Rebuildable is not the same as worth rebuilding
A mechanical movement can be stripped, cleaned, re-lubricated and reassembled indefinitely. That is why 1960s watches run today, and it is the strongest durability story on this site in principle.
In practice there is an economic threshold. A full service from an independent watchmaker typically costs 150 to 400 dollars. Below roughly 400 dollars of watch, that service costs more than a replacement - so cheap automatics are run until they stop and then replaced, whatever their theoretical rebuildability.
That threshold, not the specification sheet, is what separates a watch you will own for life from a watch you will own for a decade.
The warranties are short, and that is normal
Seiko increased its worldwide warranty to three years from 1 October 2024, which is now the longest in this group.
Hamilton publishes twenty-four months.
Tissot publishes two years, three on COSC-certified models.
Orient publishes one year on standard models, two on Orient Star.
None of these is a reason to buy or avoid a watch. The relevant question for a lifetime object is parts availability and service network, not the first two years.
Why the Hamilton is our pick to pass on
The Khaki Field Mechanical is hand-wound. No rotor, no date complication, nothing to fail that a watchmaker cannot fix with parts that will still exist in 2070 - and Swatch Group’s parts supply is the best in the industry.
Simplicity is a durability feature in watches to a degree people underestimate. Every complication is another set of parts that can wear and another reason a service costs more.
Where the threshold bites
A Seiko 5 is a genuinely rebuildable watch with the most-serviced automatic caliber in the world, and almost nobody services one, because the service costs more than the watch. That is not a criticism of the watch - it is excellent value - it is a statement about what happens to it in year fifteen.
A Seiko Prospex or a Hamilton crosses the line. A service is rational, so the watch gets serviced, so it survives. The watch did not change; the arithmetic did.
The quartz exception
The G-Shock is not rebuildable in any romantic sense - a failed module is replaced, not repaired. And it is probably the most genuinely long-lived watch on this page.
Straps, bezels and batteries are all cheap and user-replaceable, and the resin case is close to indestructible. Thirty-year-old DW5600s are in daily use everywhere. Cheap replaceable parts beat expensive serviceable ones more often than enthusiasts like to admit.
What actually ends a watch
Water ingress through perished gaskets, which is why a water-rated watch needs periodic gasket replacement to keep its rating. Impact to the movement. Corrosion from sweat under the lugs. And being lost, which genuinely accounts for a large share of watch attrition and is why the strap spring bars are worth replacing before they look worn.
For the watch you will actually wear through all of that, see automatic watches for everyday wear; and if you have not settled the movement question, automatic vs quartz takes it apart.
For the brand-specific version of the lifespan question, the average lifespan of a Hamilton watch works through why a mechanical watch has a service interval rather than a lifespan at all.